All the fun and magic of the critically acclaimed new musical comedy A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder remains alive and well on the brilliant new cast album released through Sh-K-Boom Records. You can download the original Broadway cast recording on iTunes or pre-order the CD here. Below, BroadwayBox reacts track-by-track to the first time our editorial team listened to Jefferson Mays and Bryce Pinkham perform Steven Lutvak and Robert L. Freedman’s new score. And while the album is a real hoot, nothing is like seeing it live, so get yourself to the Walter Kerr Theatre to witness the hilarious demise of the D’Ysquith dynasty.

1. Overture/Prologue: A Warning to the Audience (Company)

2. You're a D'Ysquith (Jane Carr & Bryce Pinkham)

Makes you want to march in place!

3. I Don't Know What I'd Do (Lisa O’Hare)

4. Foolish to Think (Bryce Pinkham)

Ah, romance.

5. A Warning to Monty (Company)

#Harsh. Very Dowager Countess.

6. I Don't Understand the Poor (Jefferson Mays)

7. Foolish to Think [Reprise] (Bryce Pinkham)

8. Poison in My Pocket (Bryce Pinkham & Jefferson Mays)

Yes! This is too fun. Let's all dance.

9. Poor Monty (Lisa O’Hare)

Lisa O'Hare is glorious!

10. Better With a Man (Bryce Pinkham & Jefferson Mays)

11. Inside Out (Bryce Pinkham & Lauren Worsham)

Oh, this is lovely.

12. Lady Hyacinth Abroad (Jefferson Mays & Company)

This number is everything! So many LOL moments.

13. The Last One You'd Expect (Company)

14. Why Are All the D'Ysquiths Dying (Company)

So much chair-dancing.

15. Why Are All the D'Ysquiths Dying [Reprise] (Jefferson Mays)

16. Sibella (Bryce Pinkham)

Bryce Pinkham has such a rich and beautiful voice. Each of his numbers is more beautiful than the last.

17. I've Decided to Marry You (Bryce Pinkham, Lisa O’Hare & Lauren Worsham)

18. Final Warning (Company)

What a kill joy.

19. Poison in My Pocket [Reprise] (Bryce Pinkham)

And we're back.

20. Looking Down the Barrel of a Gun (Jefferson Mays)

What Jefferson Mays has done on this album is amazing.

21. Stop! Wait! What?! (Bryce Pinkham)

22. That Horrible Woman (Lisa O’Hare & Lauren Worsham)

23. Finale (Company)

What pure joy that was to listen to. It gives you a big Broadway high.

A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder continues at Broadway’s Walter Kerr Theatre. Save up to $58 now on tickets with our BroadwayBox discount code.