While it’s hard to say goodbye to current stars Matthew James Thomas and Patina Miller, these two new headliners are getting theater fans super excited. Why you ask? Because these hot young stars can really sing—like the chill-inducing kind of singing. Need proof? Ladies first; take it away Ms. Ciara Renee.

“The Man That Got Away,” or eat your heart out Judy

If every great “Out Tonight” came together and made a baby, it would be this video

The grand finale: Ciara’s Big Fish showstopper. #Pipes

Now onto Broadway’s next Pippin the Great, Mr. Kyle Dean Massey. There are so many awesome videos of this matinee idol belting his face off, so we are going to limit it to amazing videos under 500 YouTube views.

Kyle Dean may be “Petrified” but you’d never know it from these soaring vocals

He’s “Still Standing” and we’re still watching…and chair dancing

Alright, you win. Here’s a little Gabe from Next to Normal