Skip to main content Skip to footer

10 Dream Pairs We’d Like to Reunite For Hello, Dolly!’s Cornelius & Irene

January 19th, 2016 by

BroadwayBoxCom BroadwayBox Share
10 Dream Pairs We’d Like to Reunite For Hello, Dolly!’s Cor…

Bette Midler is returning to Broadway as Dolly Levi in Hello, Dolly!, her first book musical on Broadway since Fiddler on the Roof in the late '60s. So obvi theater fans exploded with a range of reactions.

Jefferson Mays GIF- -Gentleman's Guide GIF- Lord Asquith D’Ysquith GIF

The Wiz - Brand New Day- GIF

Sister ACt GIF- Hallelujah GIF

Soon the interwebs were chatting: Who will be her love interest, Horace Vandergelder? Who will eventually go in to replace? What theatre is this going into? Ya know, chat. Meanwhile, we’re pacing the floor imagining what two young Broadway stars will play the coveted roles of Corneilus Hackl and Irene Molloy.

Hello Dolly GIF- Irene Molloy- Corneilus

The OBC of Dolly! featured Tony winner Charles Nelson Reilly (Match Game) as Cornelius and Eileen Brennan (Private Benjamin, Clue, Will & Grace) sporting ribbons down her back as Irene.

Hello Dolly- OBC

Photo by Eileen Darby/Graphic House

Now since Bette is a HUGE star, there’s a good chance that these plum roles will go to Broadway names (rather than full-out movie stars), and here are 10 pairs of performers we’d love to see reunite as Hello Dolly’s young lovers.

Santino Fontana & Laura Osnes (Cinderella)

Santino- Osnes- Cinderella

Photo by Carol Rosegg

Sure, she's in 'The Bandstand' but don't ruin this for us!

Rob McClure & Brynn O’Malley (Honeymoon in Vegas)

Rob McClure- Brynn

Bryce Pinkham & Lauren Worsham (A Gentleman’s Guide to Love & Murder)


Stark Sands & Annaleigh Ashford (Kinky Boots)


Photo by Matthew Murphy

Josh Grisetti & Sierra Boggess (It Shoulda Been You)


Photo by Bruce Glikas

John Cariani and Kate Reinders (Something Rotten!)


Photo by Joan Marcus

Max von Essen & Jill Paice (An American in Paris)

Max and Jill Paice

Photo by Bruce Glikas

Joshua Henry & Nikki Renee Daniels (Porgy and Bess)

Porgy and Bess

Photo by Joan Marcus

Tony Yazbeck & Laura Benanti (Gypsy)


Photo by Joan Marcus

Telly Leung & Katie Rose Clarke (Allegiance)

Telly- Katie

Photo by Matthew Murphy

As for their buddies Barnaby Tucker & Minnie Fay, here’s to hoping for an Alex Wyse or Jay Armstrong and a Melanie Moore or Joaquina Kalukango.

Hello Dolly Dreamcast- Barnaby Tucker- Minnie Fay- Broadway

Hello, Dolly! begins performances March 13, 2017.