Skip to main content Skip to footer
Costume Extravaganza

Kate Wetherhead Gives Us a Glimpse at the 15 Different Characters She Plays in the Lovable Off-Broadway Musical The Other Josh Cohen

December 13th, 2018 by

KateWetherhead Share
Kate Wetherhead Gives Us a Glimpse at the 15 Different Ch...

Photo by Caitlin McNaney

There are so many reasons to see the delightful and truly hilarious new off-Broadway musical The Other Josh Cohen, one of which is the unbelievable featured performance by Kate Wetherhead. The star and co-creator of Submissions Only and the book series Jack & Louisa plays 15 different characters throughout the one-act musical, ranging from an 80-something-year-old woman to Neil Diamond to a nine-year-old school crush, and slaying each and every one.

Kate Wetherhead GIF- Other Josh Cohen Off Broadway Musial

Scroll on as Kate introduces us to each of her The Other Josh Cohen characters and costumes in the photos below.

1. A Lot of People.

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


That's how I'm credited in the program, so I guess that's what I'll call my base costume.  I don't want to get too specific about this character because there's an element of surprise to her.  She comes and goes throughout the show, playing keyboard and auxiliary percussion and observing the antics of the two Josh Cohens (played by Steve Rosen and David Rossmer).

2. Opening number characters. 

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


They include a mime, an umpire, and three women who reject Josh in one way or another.  I'm lumping them all together because their flames burn fast and bright.

3. Baby.

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


She is a new co-worker of Josh's; he has a crush on her from a distance.  Their brief exchange is thwarted by a misunderstanding.

4. Betsy Clarke.

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


Nine years old, she is a classmate of a young Josh who rejects his Valentine’s Day overtures. I always pretend to be really stuffed up when I play her. I enjoy her frog earmuffs immensely.

Kate Wetherhead GIF- Other Josh Cohen Off Broadway Musial

5. Jen from Lincoln High. 

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


Described in a lyric as "a blend of Sporty Spice and Gertrude Stein," Jen is another recipient of a Valentine’s Day poem written by Josh but she is also not into it. She's got a bit of a Diane Keaton look to her. I think she's very snooty.

6. Nightmare Girl. 

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


This is an amalgam of every girl Josh has tried to date in his adulthood.  Her faux fur vest, heavy side bangs and red sunglasses make me feel appropriately nightmarish.

7. CVS Girl. 

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

She is probably the most "normal" character I play... until she's not.  I have to be coy about describing these characters because so many of them experience a turn, which is really fun when you don't see it coming. I will say her pink moto jacket has gotten a lot of positive feedback from my friends.  It might have to come home with me when the show closes in 2025.

8. Neil Diamond.

 
Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


I always knew I would play Neil Diamond one day; the similarities between us are just too uncanny.  I can't tell you how many times I've been stopped on the street, only to disappoint fans who think they're getting a chance to meet one of their idols.  At least now I get to dress like him. And that wig... Is a thing of beauty.

Kate Wetherhead GIF- Other Josh Cohen Off Broadway Musial

9. Anne Shyman. 

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


She's my favorite. If you see the show that might strike you as odd, as she's not on stage for very long, but there's just something about her that tickles me.  Those glasses make me feel like a little nerdy bug.  And she gives Josh a fantastic gift. 

10. Crazy Neighbor #3. 

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


I'll just leave that there.

11. Samuel Cohen.

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


The mischievous, libidinous, "very virile" patriarch of the Cohen family.  Nothing says sexy like a 5'2" lady in an oversized black wool coat and payot.

12. Tara Cohen.

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


Josh's sister. She has a big voice, big hair, and a big husband (Luke Darnell is SO MUCH taller than me).  She is perhaps overly concerned about Josh's well-being but it comes from a very loving place.

Kate Wetherhead GIF- Other Josh Cohen Off Broadway Musial

13. Josh's Mom.

 
Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


I'm trying (probably unsuccessfully) to mimic a woman I overheard on the street one day who sounded like she was constantly exposing her bottom her teeth as she talked.  She is not afraid to rock a sheer floral print top.  She also thinks she's a riot.

Kate Wetherhead GIF- Other Josh Cohen Off Broadway Musial

14. Irma Cohen.

 
Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

Photo by Caitlin McNaney


Once again, I must refrain from saying too much.  But I'll say that I care for Irma very deeply, and the beaded chain on her glasses is everything to me.

Kate Wetherhead GIF- Other Josh Cohen Off Broadway Musial

15. Housekeeper.

Kate Wetherhead- The Other Josh Cohen-Off Broadway Musical

She is of European descent, wears a fabulous pair of bedazzled glasses, and has a very sunny disposition. 

Seriously, don’t miss Kate Wetherhead in 'The Other Josh Cohen' at off-Broadway’s Westside Theatre.