Dreamcast

15 Roles We're Dying to See Tony Nominee Orfeh Play Someday, Somewhere, (Hopefully Broadway!)

December 8th, 2016 by

JoshuaFerri Share
15 Roles We're Dying to See Tony Nominee Orfeh Play Somed...

Tony nominated Broadway couple Andy Karl & Orfeh make their Feinstein’s/54 Below debut December 8-14 with their new show Legally Bound. Hope the roof has been reinforced because these two have a tendency to blow it off whatever building they are singing at.


After the one-two-punch of Rocky and On the Twentieth Century, Karl returns to Broadway this spring in Groundhog Day. In his New York Times review, Ben Brantley recently said the new musical transforms “Mr. Karl into the top-of-the-heap musical star he has long deserved to be”.

Andy Karl- Groundhog Day- London

Photo by Manuel Harlan


And that’s f#cking awesome, but Broadway really needs Orfeh back too. The Tony nominee for Legally Blonde who slayed the house down in Saturday Night Fever and Trailer Park needs to lend her incredible pipes to some of Broadway’s most beloved scores. Here are 15 roles we’re hoping to see Orfeh play on Broadway, off-Broadway, Encores! or a YouTube bootleg.

Vera Simpson in Pal Joey

Vera Simpson GIF- Pal Joey GIF- Stockard Channing GIF

I could close my eyes and see her slinking around with a fur and a cigarette holder as the bored, rich socialite. Plus, she’d get to sing “Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered” and “What Is a Man”.

Joanne in Company


Just imagine her doing the “when are we going to make it" scene and her belting the “rises” of “Ladies Who Lunch”. She’d bring the sex appeal and power to one of theatre’s great roles.

Fastrada in Pippin

Fastrada GIF- Pippin GIF- Chita Rivera GIF

After all she’s just an ordinary housewife and mother,  just like all you housewives and mothers out there.

Roxie Hart in Chicago

Roxie Chicago Broadway

Photo by Jeremy Daniel


WTF?! How has she not already played this role? Seriously. That “Funny Honey”...her “Roxie”...COME ON BROADWAY!

Vera Charles in Mame

Mame Vera GIF

The queen of shade Bea Arthur originated the role, we need a revival desperately (hopefully starring Jane Krakowski), and Orfeh would slay “The Man in the Moon” with her rich, low tones.

Miss Mona Stangley in The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas


This feels like a no-brainer. Also, I’d love to see her co-star in this with her hubby, Andy Karl.

The Witch in Into the Woods

The Witch Into the Woods GIF

That voice on “Stay with Me” and “Last Midnight”, serving the wretched Witch of the first act and the high glamour of act two. It would be EPIC.

Aurora in Kiss of the Spider Woman


How have we still not had a revival of this yet?! There’s something really commanding about Orfeh that I think she’d sell what needs to be sold as the vampy movie star.

Muzzy Van Hossmere in Thoroughly Modern Millie


I just want to hear what she’d do with “Only in New York” and "Long as I’m Here with You”. This role needs a diva, and she’s the one I’m rooting for.

Velma Von Tussle in Hairspray

Linda Hart GIF- Hairspray GIF- Velma GIF

The lineage should go: Linda Hart, Michelle Pfeiffer, Kristin Chenoweth, and Orfeh. She would nail the whole wicked with a wink thing you need for Velma, and sing the shit out of “Miss Baltimore Crabs”.

Aldonza in Man of La Mancha


The very least she can do is perform “It’s All the Same” in concert somewhere! This spitfire is Orfeh 101.

Georgia Wilkinson in Billy Elliot

Billy Elliot GIF- Georgia Wilkinson GIF

There’s a camp side to her that would be hilarious as the Billy Elliot dancer teacher.

Madame Giry in Love Never Dies


I get it, but if you are familiar with the Phantom sequel, you’d know what a great villain Madame Giry becomes (2:10 in this video). She would leave audiences chilled.

Margo Channing in Applause

Applause GIF- Lauren Bacall GIF

Imagine those wonderful Charles Strouse songs he wrote for Lauren Bacall but sung with all the fire and music of Orfeh.

Anna in The Rink


This would bring two things I long for together: An Orfeh return and a Rink revival. As the spicy, independent Italian mother, Orfeh would have so many opportunities to shine and remind everyone what a singular talent she is.

But until our dreams turn into reality, see Orfeh and Andy Karl in ‘Legally Bound’ at 54 December 8-14.