discount alerts
Get discount alerts
We care about your privacy.

Our new Mobile Apps - FREE

Off-Broadway Discounts
New York Reviews   London Reviews   Las Vegas Reviews   Orlando Reviews

Broadway Theater Reviews

Candid reviews written by theater goers like you!
My First Time Reviews - Broadway

My First Time Reviews

Based on 12 audience reviews
Add Review Write a Review
My First Time tickets broadway
New World Stages - Stage 5 New York
What to Expect:
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Music: Music on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Recommended For:
Adults:  grade 60
Romantic Date:  grade 40
Tourists:  grade 40
Seniors:  grade 20
Displaying 1-12 out of 12 reviews
1 Disappointing  Review by: df, Nov 8, 2009
This was, overall, not the hilarious show I was expecting. I saw it on 11/6/09. Three of the four actors were great (particularly the shorter girl with the shoulder-length straight brown hair, she was fantastic!) but the other girl was awful. Her ridiculously long dramatic pauses during her stories was bordering on excruciating, and her one-trick valley girl persona was overacted. This, in conjunction with numerous stories that were not ... read more
My recommendation:
Don't go
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Good
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Good
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Good
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
2   Review by: Tee, Jul 20, 2009
I was truly disappointed in the show. My friends and I were not entertained. What do you expect for this price. They told stories that they got off of the website but the stories went from funny to serious without time for you to change emotion so you ended up still laughing when they were talking about rape. I kept looking at watch. not a very good sign. I went with 8 of my friends and everyone felt the same.
My recommendation:
Don't go
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
Music: Music on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
I saw this show with:
Large Group
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
3 Such A Treat!  Review by: Brad, Jan 22, 2009
An really enjoyable night at the Theatre. My girlfriend and I were talking and laughing about the show and our first times for days afterward. We also now have an odd inside joke, so thanks MFT Cast!

My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Music: Music on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Romantic Date
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
4   Review by: Anna, Jan 20, 2009
My first time seeing my first time left me wanting to relive it again and again, and not just the show.
A very enjoyable night of Theatre, the way god intended...lol.
My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Music: Music on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Romantic Date
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
5 Don't go, not funny, try something different.  Review by: luvtravel, Jun 1, 2008
One of the worst shows I have ever seen. Some people were laughing, but they would laugh at anything. The only things I liked were the inclined seats, good music and informational statistics on the screen.
My recommendation:
Don't go
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
Music: Music on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Good
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
6 Love it!!! Soooo much fun!  Review by: BklynChic, Mar 2, 2008
This was one of the funniest shows I have ever seen, and I really believe some of the off-broadway shows are better than the massive productions on broadway. This show had 2 guys and 2 girls, acting out thousands of "first times"...some were hilarious.. some were more serious... when you first get into the theatre, you fill out a survey.. my card and my boyfriends cards were chosen.. but don't worry... it is annonymous. This show is definitely ... read more
My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Romantic Date, Tourists, Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
7 So much fun!  Review by: NYTG23, Jul 31, 2007
My friends and I decided to check out this show because we are big fans of Altar Boyz and thought we would check out another show from one of the creators. We didn't really know what to expect going in, (4 actors talking about first times having sex?) As it turns out, we had so much more fun than we had expected. It's actually quite funny with fantastic performances from all the actors. I highly recommend this show if you ... read more
My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Recommended for:
Romantic Date, Business Assoc., Tourists
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
8 Disappointed  Review by: Disappointed, Jul 30, 2007
I was interested in the topic and the new theater that it was located in. However, I was disappointed in show. Two of the actors are very good but the other two are very amateurish. It also seemed very repetitive even though it was only an hour long. Don't expect a legitimate show...it is really just 4 people sitting on stools talking to the audience.
My recommendation:
Don't go
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Good
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Poor
Recommended for:
Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
9 My First Time!  Review by: theaterfan945, Jul 30, 2007
I walked into the theater expecting to see a simple show made up of stories. We sat down and filled out a questioner that was on the seats. When the show started I was amazed by how Davenport had combined thousands of stories into one laugh out loud show. It keeps you on the edge of your seat right up to the end of the show. Enjoy it!
My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Music: Music on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
10 Great Show!  Review by: skichic726, Jul 30, 2007
This show is made up of stories submitted by people just like you and me. Combined will utter seamlessness. This show will have you laughing on the edge of your seat for a full hour and a half. Highly recommend this show!
My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Recommended for:
Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
11 Funny Firsts  Review by: Jessica, Jul 18, 2007
Super fun show. Me and my friends went and laughed the entire time.
My recommendation:
must see!
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
I saw this show with:
Large Group
Recommended for:
Business Assoc., Seniors, Tourists
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
12 My First Time  Review by: Katie, Jul 15, 2007
My First Time is a brilliant show that is just as interesting as the title sounds. This show remains faithful to delivering the true stories of people's first sexual experiences and shedding some light on a subject many find to be off limits. The acting is impeccable and the execution of the production is flawless. I could not stop myself from laughing almost the entire night. Each actor brings a different element to My First Time and does ... read more
My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the My First Time has been rated as Excellent
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Romantic Date, Seniors, Tourists
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for My First Time tickets Broadway
* Review is an opinion of a BroadwayBox user and not that of BroadwayBox.com and BroadwayBox, Inc.
Sign Up!
Free Discount Newsletter
Tell-A-Friend about BroadwayBox.com
Your E-Mail
Friend's E-Mail

Message:
Find Show By Category
Testimonials
I did in fact get on and managed to get front row ... -Nicole more
Thank you - what a great deal -Sheryl
It is a wonderful service. I am so glad I found it -MarSH
More... Add