discount alerts
Get discount alerts
We care about your privacy.

Our new Mobile Apps - FREE

Off-Broadway Discounts
New York Reviews   London Reviews   Las Vegas Reviews   Orlando Reviews

Broadway Theater Reviews

Candid reviews written by theater goers like you!
American Buffalo Reviews - Broadway

American Buffalo Reviews

Based on 7 audience reviews
Add Review Write a Review
American Buffalo tickets broadway
Belasco Theatre New York
What to Expect:
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Music:
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Good
Recommended For:
Adults:  grade 80
Business Assoc.:  grade 30
Anyone:  grade 20
Tourists:  grade 10
Displaying 1-7 out of 7 reviews
1 See them , But if you can see in the Movies..IT would be ALOT Cheaper !!  Review by: Javy, Nov 25, 2008
Saw the Saturday Evening show. I Have to say that Cedric the Entertainer held his own with John. But you can see at times that he was very rhythmic and did not give total expression until the last act. Haley was very plain and did a lot of reactionary acting, a lot of taking from the other actors and not showing his character. As for John, He is a veteran of the stage and he carried the first act by himself, either accidental or intentional. ... read more
My recommendation:
Go see if you get a chance
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Good
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Poor
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Poor
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for American Buffalo tickets Broadway
2   Review by: SeverelyDisappointed, Nov 20, 2008
Saw a preview of the play before its grand opening. While there was obvious flow issues due to line problems, the play, plot, and lines themselves left much to be desired. It wasn't very entertaining. All three actors performed their roles well, but didn't have much to go with. Despite two big comedic names, there is little humor. I've seen over 30 shows on Broadway and this by far was the most disappointing of all I've seen. If you are ... read more
My recommendation:
Don't go
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Poor
I saw this show with:
Business Associate
Recommended for:
Business Assoc., Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for American Buffalo tickets Broadway
3   Review by: Tex, Nov 18, 2008
The New York Times review said it all.
The night I saw AB it was so uneven. I kept wondering why it wasn't as wonderful as Speed The Plow. The story was long and boring.
Cedric was the only one who appeared to have a real character. It was an impressive B'way debut for a stand up comic. John L. was all over the place. Haley Joel seemed to mope around. The pacing was so slow then I realized it was because of line trouble. ... read more
My recommendation:
Don't go
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Poor
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Poor
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Anyone
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for American Buffalo tickets Broadway
4 DISAPPOINTING  Review by: Sandy, Nov 16, 2008
This show was a huge disappointment, the only saving grace was an amazing cast. I was pleasantly surprised at Cedric's ability to play a non-comedic part. Hayley Joel was impressive and Leguizamo provided the only comic relief. However, the plot fell short, and I didn't feel a connection to any of the characters. I would not recommend this show.
My recommendation:
Don't go
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Good
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Poor
I saw this show with:
Family
Recommended for:
Tourists, Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for American Buffalo tickets Broadway
5 Loved the Cast  Review by: abeachcomer, Nov 13, 2008
Enjoyed the cast. Though you don't imagine this particular cast for this show I was impressed with Cedric the Entertainer. John L was awesome and Haley was good for a broadway debut. If you never have seen a broadway show this may not be the one to start with but definately worth seeing.
My recommendation:
Go see if you get a chance
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Good
I saw this show with:
Family
Recommended for:
Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for American Buffalo tickets Broadway
6 TALENT OUTWEIGHS TEDIUM  Review by: , Nov 2, 2008
WORTH SEEING FOR THE ACTING AND PRODUCTION. PLAY ITSELF IS VERY TEDIOUS AND LACKS THE SENSE OF INVOLVEMENT WITH THE PROTAGONISTS WHICH IS TYPICAL OF MAMET'S OTHER PLAYS.
My recommendation:
Go see if you get a chance
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Poor
I saw this show with:
Spouse/Partner
Recommended for:
Business Assoc., Seniors, Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for American Buffalo tickets Broadway
7 Surprising, unforgettable and funny  Review by: nyinsider, Oct 23, 2008
Unforgettable and brilliant casting
My recommendation:
must see!
Acting: Acting on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Production: Production on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
Story: Story on the American Buffalo has been rated as Excellent
I saw this show with:
Business Associate
Recommended for:
Romantic Date, Business Assoc., Adults
Was this review helpful?   YesYES   NoNO View Available Discounts for American Buffalo tickets Broadway
* Review is an opinion of a BroadwayBox user and not that of BroadwayBox.com and BroadwayBox, Inc.
Sign Up!
Free Discount Newsletter
Tell-A-Friend about BroadwayBox.com
Your E-Mail
Friend's E-Mail

Message:
Testimonials
Your website is just great! Thank you so much for ... -VH more
It was great. Dont change a thing. Thanks -Olv
I go to NYC once a year. I do think you have a gre... -Oleg more
More... Add
Find Show By Category