Two Tony Award-winning legends of the musical theater, composer John Kander and actress Sutton Foster, celebrate their shared birthday today, March 18. At first, we thought maybe cast Sutton in John’s iconic musicals (Roxie, Sally, Angel, Flora, Auroa), but then we found this clip from the Amy Sherman-Palladino TV series Bunheads where Sutton performs both Chicago and Cabaret, and that seemed like a sign. So, enjoy these iconic B’way Pisces coming together for “Me and My Baby” from Chicago and “Maybe This Time” from Cabaret.

For more Sutton Foster, check out this interview where she reveals the stories behind some of her most iconic YouTube clips. For more John Kander, check out this playlist of our favorite Kander & Ebb tunes.